Net Neutrality and Business Videoconferencing

Something that’s bothered me for a while now, but an issue I put to one side (until yesterday) is the question of what happens if the backbone ISP’s get to the point where they refuse to continue investing in bandwidth across peering points?

Many in the VC industry, including myself have relied on the perpetuation of bandwidth across the internet expanding ad-infinitum, keeping step with consumer demand.  This has meant, in the main, that VC call quality over the internet has been perfectly adequate for most meetings, and an enabler of new working practices (home and remote workers for example).

Whilst I don’t profess to be an expert in ISP peering economics, I did wonder if there would ever be a situation where diminishing returns (or increased power and control) for these ISPs would result in them holding the rest of the internet to ransom, to renegotiate the terms of how they generate money for their bandwidth.

And so now we see the first incidence of this behaviour with Comcast brokering a huge deal with Netflix, a large contributor to internet bandwidth growth in the past 5 years, and accounting for a third of US internet bandwidth consumption.


We saw something similar unfold in the UK, with ISP’s twice demanding more revenue from the BBC resulting from the launch of its iPlayer service, and again when iPlayer offered HD content.  It took UK government intervention to prevent the ISP’s from changing the model.

So what do this mean for business video communications?

The precedent set by Comcast/Netflix is concerning.  Already businesses are using the internet on an increasing basis to conduct its video meetings, whether this be WebEx, BlueJeans or other Internet based service providers.

Video service users within organisations are typically unaware that internet based services of this kind are provided without any kind of SLA.  But until now that’s been ok, the Internet has been fine at coping with the growth in demand for bandwidth.

This might be about to change.  Comcast/ Netflix sets a worrying precedent where the deliberate inaction of ISP to invest in their core and peering bandwidths becomes a legitimate practice to secure greater revenues from organisations that generate high bandwidth internet traffic.

We already see internet providers today specifically geared to providing ‘quality assured’ internet transit for video communications.  Could this become the norm for Business video communications?

Whatever we have in store, it’s only likely to drive up costs.

One mitigation strategy could be for customers to use fixed connectivity into videoconferencing clearinghouses / service providers.  This approach provides cost certainty, and importantly an SLA.


3 thoughts on “Net Neutrality and Business Videoconferencing

  1. One issue I have seen with bandwidth increasing is that websites and some communication formats have become lazy (subjective opinion). Why optimise to load fast/utilise minimum bandwidth when you just hope ever increasing speeds mitigate the need.
    I recently used a carriers voice app over my fibre connection and found that it seemed to be using so much bandwidth that everything else ran very slow. Yet my old Tandberg 1700 can do a decent multipoint call.
    We can’t keep expecting someone else to throw infrastructure and bandwidth to cover OTT solutions. I rarely watch over the air programs now and mainly watch streamed/downloaded content. Probably better that you pay a portion of the costs within the service charge of the services you use rather than line costs increasing for everyone.

  2. Times, they are a changing Dave! I do think that we will end up with a 2-tier internet after this deal. The old model may or may not have worked for the ISPs, but Comcast managed to accumulate enough power to set this precedent, and it’s only a matter of time now before other ISP’s follow suit.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s